"Gen Z is the first generation to grow up with smartphones, and they are facing an unprecedented mental health crisis because of it." – Jonathan Haidt, The Anxious Generation

‍

Madison, a bright fifteen-year-old, sits across from me, her eyes downcast. "It's like everyone else has it all figured out but me." she confesses, her voice tinged with despair. She spends hours scrolling through social media, comparing her life to the meticulously curated images of others. This constant comparison leaves her feeling inadequate, anxious, and overwhelmed. Maddie's story is far from unique—it's becoming an all-too-common narrative in the digital age, underscoring a mental health crisis that demands our urgent attention.

The rise of smartphoneMadison sat across from me, her eyes downcast as she described the overwhelming anxiety she felt each day. At just fifteen, she found herself constantly comparing her life to the curated images on social media. "It's like everyone else has it all figured out, and I'm just... lost," she confided. Madison’s story is becoming all too common in the digital era, highlighting a mental health crisis that demands urgent attention—not just from parents and caregivers, but from Gen Z themselves.

As the first generation to grow up immersed in smartphones and social media, Generation Z faces unique challenges that have profound implications for their mental health. In The Anxious Generation, Jonathan Haidt explores these issues in depth, offering insights that are crucial for anyone involved in the care and development of young people. For those of you navigating these challenges in Vancouver, Sidney, and Victoria, understanding these dynamics is essential in taking control of your mental health and well-being.

The Surge in Mental Health Issues

In the early 2000s, mental health among preteens and adolescents seemed relatively stable. However, the past decade has seen a dramatic rise in anxiety, depression, and self-harm. A US National Survey on Drug Use and Health reveals a staggering 145% increase in reported depressive episodes among girls since 2012, and a 161% increase among boys. College students have experienced significant spikes in mental health issues, with anxiety rising by 134%, depression by 106%, ADHD by 72%, and bipolar disorder diagnoses by 57%.

These alarming statistics are mirrored by an increase in emergency room visits for self-harm and a surge in suicide rates. Among girls, ER visits for self-harm have increased by 188% since 2010, with a 167% rise in suicide rates. Boys have seen a 48% increase in self-harm-related ER visits and a 91% increase in suicide rates. These trends suggest a significant mental health crisis that is hitting Gen Z particularly hard.

The Impact of Smartphones and Social Media

What accounts for this dramatic shift in mental health? One of the primary factors is the widespread adoption of smartphones. Introduced in 2007 and widely adopted by the 2010s, smartphones have fundamentally changed the way young people interact, communicate, and engage with the world.

Studies show that before smartphones became ubiquitous, adolescents were generally happier than their Gen X predecessors. However, the constant connectivity enabled by smartphones has had a detrimental impact. By 2016, 79% of teens owned a smartphone, and a 2022 Pew Research Center report indicates that 46% of teens describe themselves as being online "almost constantly."

This constant online presence, referred to as the “Great Rewiring of Childhood,” has shifted the social lives of young people from face-to-face interactions to virtual ones. As your social lives moved online, the mental health of Gen Z deteriorated. This trend isn’t just happening in the US—similar findings have been reported in Canada, the UK, and the Nordic states, suggesting this is a global phenomenon.

Erosion of Play-Based Childhood

The introduction of smartphones has eroded the traditional play-based childhood that is essential for healthy development. Human childhood is uniquely long, allowing for a critical process of synaptic pruning, where frequently used connections are strengthened, and rarely used ones fade away. This development happens through free play, attunement, and social learning—areas that smartphones disrupt.

Free Play

Unstructured, undirected play is crucial for learning cooperation, risk assessment, friendship formation, and imagination. In contrast, a phone-based childhood is structured and designed by experts, lacking the developmental opportunities offered by physical play. This lack of free play deprives you of critical experiences that foster resilience and problem-solving abilities.

Attunement

Attunement involves connecting with others through synchronous interactions, vital for developing emotional self-regulation and social skills. Excessive social media use diminishes opportunities for attunement, as digital communication lacks the depth and nuance of face-to-face interactions. This deficit can lead to difficulties in forming meaningful relationships and managing emotions effectively.

Social Learning

While social media can enhance social learning by allowing you to identify behaviors to emulate, it also exposes you to inappropriate role models and sets impossible standards. The metrics of likes and comments can warp your understanding of self-worth, leading to anxiety and a distorted self-image. Real-world role models and experiences are necessary for developing a healthy sense of self.

The Four Core Harms of Smartphones

Smartphones have inflicted four core harms on the mental well-being of young people: social deprivation, sleep deprivation, attention fragmentation, and addiction.

Social Deprivation

The time spent interacting face-to-face has dropped markedly. Even when you’re with friends, you might often find yourselves distracted by your phones, which diminishes the quality of interactions. This trend extends to family life, where many young people report that their parents are often "distracted" by smartphones, leading to a breakdown in family communication and bonding.

Sleep Deprivation

Late-night phone use disrupts sleep, exacerbating issues like depression, anxiety, aggression, and impeded impulse control. A review of 36 studies shows a clear relationship between smartphone use and sleep deprivation among adolescents. Poor sleep quality not only impacts mood and cognitive function but also increases the risk of long-term mental health issues.

Attention Fragmentation

The average teen receives eleven notifications per waking hour, pulling attention away from tasks and compromising your ability to focus deeply. This continuous distraction can prevent the full maturation of focus and attention capabilities, contributing to the rise in ADHD diagnoses. Research from Harvard University highlights the link between screen time and attention problems, making this a critical area of concern.

Addiction

Smartphones and social media are designed to be habit-forming and addictive. Preteens and teens are particularly vulnerable, with variable rewards (likes, comments) creating compulsive habits. The resulting dopamine rush is countered by withdrawal symptoms such as irritability and anxiety. Studies have shown that social media addiction can have a profound impact on mental health, leading to increased rates of depression and anxiety.

Addressing the Crisis

Addressing the negative impacts of smartphones on your mental health requires a proactive approach, both at the societal level and within your own life.

Limit Screen Time

For younger children, minimize screen time and maximize opportunities for free, unstructured play. For teens, start setting boundaries on when and where screen use is allowed. Consider establishing tech-free zones in your home, like the dining room, and tech-free times, like during meals and before bed.

Encourage Independence

As you enter elementary school and beyond, engage in activities that promote independence, like walking to school or participating in team sports. These experiences foster self-efficacy and resilience, which are critical for mental well-being.

Develop Competence

Focus on building competence through real-world experiences. Whether it’s mastering a new skill, taking on responsibilities at home, or engaging in part-time jobs or outdoor activities, these experiences help you develop a strong sense of self and purpose.

Practical Steps for Gen Z

Taking charge of your mental health in the digital age involves making conscious choices. Here are some practical steps:

  • Establish Tech-Free Zones and Times: Create spaces in your life where screens are off-limits, like during meals or before bed.
  • Encourage Outdoor Activities: Spend more time outdoors, whether it’s hiking, biking, or just taking a walk. Nature Canada offers programs that encourage engagement with the natural world.
  • Model Healthy Behavior: Set an example for your peers by managing your screen time and demonstrating a balanced lifestyle.
  • Communicate Openly: Talk about the dangers of excessive screen time and the importance of face-to-face interactions with friends and family.
  • Monitor Usage: Use tools like Bark or Qustodio to monitor and limit screen time effectively.

Final Thoughts

The widespread adoption of smartphones has been the primary driver behind the dramatic surge in mental health challenges facing Gen Z. By limiting screen time, maximizing opportunities for unstructured play, and encouraging independence in the real world, you can help nurture your mental well-being in the digital age. Understanding the complex interplay between technology, social interaction, and adolescent development is crucial for developing effective strategies to support your mental health.

If you’re struggling with anxiety or other mental health issues, it’s important to seek support. In Vancouver, Sidney, and Victoria, counsellors like Robin Evan Willis specialize in anxiety counselling and are dedicated to helping you navigate the challenges of the digital age. Schedule your appointment to start your journey towards a healthier, happier future.